How Does Your IRA Compare to Others Your Age?
Traditional and Roth IRAs grow differently. Roth leads in the 20s and 30s — younger savers overwhelmingly prefer it. By the late 40s, Traditional surges ahead driven by large 401(k) rollovers averaging $116,500 each. SEP IRAs, used by the self-employed, track closely with Traditional after age 40.
In 2023, $653 billion rolled from 401(k)s and pensions into Traditional IRAs — vs. just $89 billion in new contributions across all IRA types.
One average rollover of $116,500 adds more to a Traditional IRA than 15+ years of maxing out a Roth at today's $7,500 limit.
Rollovers peak at ages 60–64 when most retirements occur: $197.7 billion flowed in that bracket alone — more than double the 55–59 bracket.
Getting started is the barrier — not the contribution limit. Participation never breaks 11% even in the peak years, meaning roughly 9 out of 10 eligible filers didn't contribute to an IRA in 2023. Among the small fraction who do, nearly half put in the full annual maximum — consistent savers tend to stay consistent.
Participation drops sharply after 70 because Required Minimum Distributions begin at 73, shifting the focus from accumulation to distribution. Many people at these ages are drawing from IRAs rather than adding to them.
Why the bottom 5% average ($101k) is higher than the 5–10% ($79k): The lowest-income bracket includes many retirees who have stopped working — their current income is low, but they accumulated substantial IRAs over decades. The 5–10% bracket skews younger and lower-earning with less time to save.
Higher income = much higher participation. The top 1% participate at 19.5% — more than 6× the rate of the bottom quartile. Access to IRAs is universal, but the propensity and capacity to contribute is strongly tied to income.
The most striking finding: Single women have larger average IRAs than single men — $164,143 vs $134,485. The overall gender gap ($164k vs $248k) is almost entirely driven by married couples, where men's balances are 81% higher on average.
The likely explanation: in households with a primary earner and a spouse who worked less or took time off, the primary earner's 401(k) rollovers flow into the traditional IRA. Since men are more often the higher earner in joint-filing households, their IRA balances reflect larger rollover accumulations from employer plans.
Worth noting: men and women hold nearly the same number of IRA accounts (34.8M vs 36.3M), so the gap is in balance size, not account ownership.
A benchmark is a starting point, not a destination.
What matters most is whether your savings — combined with Social Security and other income — will cover what you plan to spend in retirement. Let's review your full picture together.